No, I really do have much to comment on it. Yes! I was not expecting this to be happen at that day. This does have some means to his singing, this doesn’t some connection to hs performance. was expecting Karunya/ Sandeep to be there. It was all about calculations, after Abhijee Sawant, whole Bombay was looking at Amay date, neverhave been rated above Meenal Jain, never have been rated Panna Gill by Judges. The positive things about Amay were his presentation, presentation of songs and presentation of himself, his voice waS not limited as Karunya’s is. Hold it, hold your fires, I really do not want to mess up with Amay’s supporters, but you all really know that even you were not supporting him from the begining. No question at all on that whatever have been happened was right or not. Many things has been wrong here and in other shows. Do you think that Sagar Sawarkar was given the proper chance? Do yuo think that Ravi Tripathi should stay in the show after making the worst ever in the show? Do you think that Panna should leave the show at that moment? Was the decision to pick up a boy in place of a girl was right at all? Why Judges specially Sonu NIgam was too harse over the sweet voice and the most happening and charming personality MOnali Thakur? Were all of you were expecting Meenal Jain’s Vote Out at that day? Why Sonu started and then used to comment on Sandeep, the most sweetest voice of Indian Idol? How could a Judge like Diya Mirza could say that she will stop watching the show, if Karunya came out? A lot of question marks… But we all have accepted those decisions. No one including Karunya was well in Shadi Round, but so much praise?? Really ridiculas, even Sifymax made the title of the recap with a contestent’s name. When we all have accepted all of the last decisions, we all know about the format, we all know that four are remained and one has to go, we all know that Amay was always above or below average (but just consistently now bad), then how could Judges dare to walk out from the show?? Have they forgot that what comments they have made over his last performances, or I should rewrite what ever they have said in each episode for Amay? Why the whole drama? Because it was the semi-final and there should be a bang before going for whole week voting? The same drama was in SRGMP when the four contestents were remaining. I am going to repeat some of my words about the format being adapted here. A song is created by four people: The writer, then the music director, then the singer and then the coreographer. The writer has no means here as the singers are singing the songs from old films, so nothing to do about that. So,why the triplet concepts is here, I think that the answer is clear. But Sonu NIgam is not here to sing, Anu Malik is not here to Direct Music and Farah is not here to coreograph. Why they are here? Not to judge the contestents, that part is done now. You are commenting to make views of public. Public have to decide that you are saying right or not. You are not the God, so can’t expect from public that they will follow you. You are getting paid for making the show interesting, you are getting votes costing Rs.3/- each from public. Public, who not always buy your 50/- album necessarily , how you could dare to think that they would go through your voice for spending thousand from their pocket money. Yes! regionalism is here and it is in the blood of India and will be. If this regionalism have costed us many times then rewarded to many times. NO, I am not favouring regionalism, but this is reality show and that’s it. you are getting money from it. If you walk out then you are making shit of the lakhs of money that people have spent on your stupid show for their candidate that is not liked by you. NOte that this show is not here because you like it, it is here because people like it. Note that you are here to perform your jobs and not to decide the fate of anyone, have you decided the fate that Anuj should not be in finals? Note that Amay’s fans missed to pay that much money to make him stay, missed that crazyness and they paid for that. But you really ruined him forever. It will increase your ratings exactly before going for the open week SMS’s. You have done what you have to do, public really do not know that how many quality singers, you failed to choose in your expert deciding style “in one minutes choose a singer”. What is the reason that the singing quality in Indian Idol is so much below than SRGMP? I do not think that in India we have so crisis of singer that they might not be involved in the process of selection. I have seen more than three singer in my eyes and heard them live,who did not make it into the piano round at least. It is your fault, if you have decided the winner before more than six weeks, not Indian public’s. You were the bunch of fools, who always call us fools and using your moronship on the singers who are chosen by you all from thousands and thousands of people. Either you are wrong now or will wrong then.
One thing that was most interesting and noticable in the Holi round was the comeback of Sandeep Acharya’s comeback. You all have heard his words, what he have said when he was in bottom two with Antra. This time he neither cried nor made any excuses. He was really expecting that day as his last day and many of us too.
Although Antra was bad in last Gala and was loosing support day by day, because of breakng of that “Gaon Ki Gori” image and her arrogance, but the Judges and some of you were expecting that this is the fate of Sandeep, and now you accept or not, many of you abusing him now, were then really praying that somehow he should stay in place of Antra.
The prays got paid, the fate chaged and the non-deserving at that moment left the show. Sandeep was not up to the mark in that show for me too, because it was not his sweet voice but it was clearly visible that he was stretching his voice to get away from his orginal, to get away from the shades of Udit Narayan adn was definately unable to handle the amount of pressure with a new type of thing. But he survived, the love of public made him to survive.
The last Gala, the holi round and Sandeep decided to make it as the final chance as Ravi Tripathi did at his last chance and the thing dramatically changed, no perssure of Sonu Nigam could make him nervous now. He was performing to make his best and also not expecting to survive and he banged, banged at both the chances.
It mad me to think about Neha Kakkar’s bang, he mad me to thank the God for us all of our wishes, what we have made for Sandeep. The bang even shakened others peformances and also stunned Judges, who were ready with their predecided comments.
Many of you love Amay for his performance and his consistency, but you have to accept that he was not upto the mark because of the choice of song first time and hen because of nervousness and pressure for the second time. Anuj Sharma, I think getting paid for the best performances during piano and theator rounds, but now even he knows that it is very very late now.
I challenge you alll that you all have a soft corner for Sandeep Acharya. The same shy looking, sweet handsome guy just like Abhijeet Sawant, the very very good boy at the next door image and in deed he is. Never knows that what to do and when to do but never did never say wrong to someone, make mistake and accept mistakes, no arrogance at any stage.
Think that why you all were expecting from the bottom of your heart, such a comeback from him and when he did it, many new supporters comeback to show and to save him for this time and now on. The bar of votes raises and it made the unexpected happening. If you all were not expecting Amay to go then I too was not expecting Anuj to come in bottom two, bcause he never touched the bottom means a strong fan list is backing him, but it was only Sandeep’s performance that broke the fate.
I have said before that week “if Sandeep survived then he will be unstoppable otherwise we all will forget him like Ravi Tripathi, Monali Thakur and Neha Kakkar”.
He did it for the first time with Sukhwindar’s voice and Amit Ji’s voice, he challenged Karunya in his high pitch field and made it. Amay’s fan shold get a new face in Sandeep. Just think about, Karunya is good because got 50% times Sukhwindar song an two Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan songs, he is peforming well because the India’s best singer is backing him at his full power. His comments are affecting the other Judges to say good things about him, he is almost declared winner before six week ahead of finals. NO, we can’t put Karunya and Sandeep side by side in this situation.
Karunya’s voice could not even be compared with Sandeep Acharya.
Karuya is trained but not gifted singer, has a well controlled voice and excelent performance but not that softness and sweetness and the performance goes by confidence. As a human bean, you could never rate him over Sandeep and do not ever dare to do that. Just decided, we got our star.
Three competitors: one got many praises from public and Judges, one in whom I always believed and you all too, from somewhere inside your heart you all are praying each time that he should bang the whole world now. In deed the best one, voice wise and the person wise, how this voice will go ahead is in your hands.
The third one, after Ravi Tripathi, most hated one, but it can’t help as no negative votes are here and many people still want to give him one more chance. He never came in bottom three/two except the last time. All the criticism is going to raise the number of votes for him and if you have to vote him out then the number of votes are needed to be increased which has lesser probability as after Amay a part of Mumbai supporters are expected to be out from the show.
If you do not join to save Sandeep, then even if Karunya faces Anuj Sharma in Finals then you belive it or not he will be defeated and youall will crying just like this time, note that he never caem down even you expected him to be at a lot of times. Anuj Sharma’s suporter are following the same way as done by Debojeet although Anuj Sharma is no where near Debojeet.
We all need to wake up otherwise we are surely going to get Anuj Sharma as Indian Idol because Karunya never got that appeal that Sandeep, Monali, Panna and Neha Kakkar has, judges made him star, ut in finals, there will be many days and nights to vote, what will happen, you all know very well. He is lacking the likability, he is lacking the X-factor, he is lacking the attitude that make you lovable.
So, whomever you ght be supporting till yet, it is the time to support Sandeep, I am not saying that do it right now wait for his performance in next gala and then decide, I have full confidence in him that he will bang you all again this time. About karunya I have to see how many hgh pitch song our Film ndustry has and how many songs Sukhwindar has sang.
You all have to make it this time, this is the time to raise the number of SMS, calls to the mark that Sandeep/ Karunya could survive, otherwise we are not going to enjoy the finals.
NOw at the same time, note that you can’t vote out Anuj Sharma but you could make Sandeep/Karunya to win over him by huge margins. So, what are you waiting for? If you have spend the money till yet then it is not the time to leave the show. You are here to make the a final shape of your investement done till yet, otherwise all will go in vain.
The situation has been changed a lot this week.
One strong contestent personwise have left the show, everything has been shakened, TRP rating has been raised, not only because of controversy but also because of the level of performances. Neck to Neck fight between Karunya and Sandeep. If any one still doubt on the quality of Sandeep then go for the recordings of the last Gala more and more. He was the best and clearly stolen the show for the first time. And what a magic was in air, never been seen after Monali Thakur and Neha Kakkar.
One could feel the magic, if he has heard all the last show and then hear the same show again and again without any reservations. If you missed the last Gala then ask me for that at email@example.com but should see that because if you missed the show, then you missed the best show of Indian Idol 2 till yet.
The person, whose tears make Judges and public in tears. The person whose smile from heart, shyness on little bit of praise make everyone of you to smile, either you are fan of him or not. You never want to make him out, even if he goes down in performance. His just a little bit enjoyment in his performance make you all to whisling. What is the meaning of a star? What is the meaning of love? Think and then speak, then dare to write a word against him. Why, why you might not be voting for him but always watching him, watching for his smile, his style and for everything. Is not that star material?
Many of you were asking for a Grand Finale between Amey and Karunya but why not it happened??
What your competitor need more to do competite with him?
what made him to get in to this level of cometition?
Who is backing Sandeep Acharya from the begining?
What his fans do?
A lot of questions are waiting for me to answer.
Ok! You wanna competite Sandeep’s fans.
Wanna competite with one who is working for overtime, a total of 16 hours a day, because he has spend his all salary in voting and now needs more and more for the last three finals.
Wanna competite with the girl, who is spending five hours daily to make her girl hostel and University voting for sandeep.
Wanna competite with boy, who has made sketches of Sandeep Acharya and now going Shop to Shop to request Shopkeepers to keep these hand made poster in front of the showcase.
Wanna competite with the old man, who came everyday at my home to saw the show, because he has not a TV in his home and he want to see Sandeep Acharya?
Wanna competite my six year niece, who speak loudly at every peformance of Sandeep, “Record it Bhaiya”.
No, you just can’t, you can’t competite the X-factor he has. You in similar way neglected Kazi Taukeer’s fan crowd and doing the same with Sandeep. Neither Judges nor public were able to stop the overflowing charm of the performances of Kazi nor they would be able to do the same with sandeep Acharya. If you were able then he was out wth Monali and Neha, you won over them but not over Sandeep as God was always with him.
Note that all the above example are from Allahabad, a district of Uttar Pradesh. Just think that what the craze will be in Rajasthan or on the peak in Bikaner itself.
Note it down, this is India, here we do not praise our Heros, we worship them. You might abuse us, you might make joke of us, you might be posting messages and message, you might making controversies, you migh be crying at top of your voice against news channels, but could not even think to competite with that much craze.
I do not know that who is supporting to whom, I do not know what are the straitegies of other contestents, I forgot that my first love was Monali for this show, I forgot that it was Neha Kakkar’s smile, which one time made me believe that she will make it, I forgot what I have said earliar on the board for the other contestents, just forgot what the persons on this board have said to me, What I remember, what I know right now is this, only this that We have to make it, if not now then never. We have to prove to prove that we are Indians.
Let Sonu say that this made us GULAM for years, but this is the spirit that make our culture alive from years when it losted from many porttion of the world. India is not known for regionalism but it is known for being emotional, that is what, which make it worst, that is what, which make it great and that emotion is with Sandeep Acharya.
Yes!! I have said earliar that “Never Sleep at Monday Night”, and now it is for all over the week, but we will not let down the spirit, each day will be a new Monday, if we make him up to the finals then we will make the history again as we have done in case of Kazi Taukeer.
I request you all to come and be a part of the history.
Now, we are at the finest edge of the competition. The people, who were started believing that this Indian Idol is going to simple inspite of a series of shocking results, I think they have got their answers.
What is needed to be an Indian Idol?
A question that have been asked so many times and a lot of diffrent kind of answers but one thing is sure as have been said by all judges that he/she should sing well and perform well, why they have said so, why they do not go only for singing, or only performance? Because there is a vote system and we all have seen how the vote system goes on.
There will always be a differnce between trained and gifted singer.
If you have to see the best of trained voice from Karunya then go for “Lagan Lagi” performance by him, that was only performance of him that impressed me.
If you have to see the gifted voice, then see “Kaun Hai Jo Sapapno Mein Aaya”, “Main Yahan Hoon Yahan” and the superb one that I liked most “Holi Khele Rakhubira”, although that was a rocking and cheerfull knock but it made many of us to tears, the happiness because our wait for that Sandeep paid off. Kabhi Kabhi hum apane bachcho se/ Apane karibi dosto se bhi naraaj ho jate hai but our hearts from the inner corners always pray for the moment when they come back on the track. I never left the belief in Sandeep and I always found it on the mark excpt Shadi round wheer his voice quality was good but confidence was not that much. Even I really liked his “Lagaan” performance acccording to the voice.
What else you needed for being Indian Idol, one who make you feel the song, one you make you think about him/her, one whose a slight sign on his face make you to emotions.
I never thought that I will ever see someone even comparable to Kazi’s Magic as I even not rate Abhijeet Sawant more than him according to the charm. Kazi was definately a youth icon because of his attitude and style.
But I found Sandeep Acharya as an anser, I know you will argue a lot of technicalities, but I go for the likability, even if you are give the chance to meet someone between Sandeep and Karunya, then you are going to choose Sandeep Acharya. If some father has to marry his daughter then he will choose Sandeep Acharya. If someone has to choose one from contestents for a date then you are going to choose Sandeep Acharya. IF Kazi was youth icon then Sandeep is just lovely and as simple as he could be. Only he could accept that Amey helped him in that performance, only he could say sorry for being out of Sur and only only he could make thanks to Sonu Nigam who was clearly artificial and very limited while praising the performance, the best peformance of that day “Holi Khele Raghubira”.
Although Amey also seems to me a personwise good but at the Neha’s vote out time, he seems to me some kind of artificial and also promoting himself, I do not know that I was right or not, but he always went under my doubt after that and I felt sorry if I was wrong. Amey has did nothing what he should not do at the vote out time, because Mini Mathur told him to do that what he did. He knows that nothing like rematch is going to be happened and the best option was that he has taken. Even the controvrsies that had been raised, I claim that it was a stage drama, triggered by Sonu Nigam and others. Anu Malik always looked to be against from the decision. It was sure that the drama is not going to happen, if Sonu Nigam have not triggered the same. I seriously say you all to think about that Amey was not the favourie candidate of Sonu Nigam and everyone rated Sandeep and Karunya to be the toppers for the day and the bottom two were obvious inspite of proper performances of Amey, then why such a strong reaction. You know that one always has to go.
One more point that he was in SRGMP 1999 where Sonu Nigam was Anchor itself and Shreya Ghoshal was winner, is making me soft about him, although when I was writing this post, then I do not know about the fact. This fact is forcing me to see the thing in another view.
I know the above para is making me at the Gunpoint of Amey’s fans, while I am already at the Gunpoint of Karunya’s fan, but I am really really sorry, if I do not feel like them for Amey. For them I have to say that Amey was the third according to me personwise after Sandeep then Monali and then Amey. These three are not only good but really rally caring for their fans and friends near them. You all Amey’s fan knows that most of the times, I tried my best to never go against Amey Date, I hope that you all will appreciate my view even if you do not like it.
I have not going as ridiculas as Diya Mirza did that I am not going to believe in Indian Idol, if Sandeep does not win, but I have to say that I will be disappointed a lot with lakhs of my friends. I am assuring Sandeep that even Judges like Sonu Nigam may be campagianing for Karunya, but It is not going to stop you, it has no problem that you have not so much good comemnts to make a VT for you. But I am sure that you will never be ashamed of any moment which you have spend in Indian Idol 2. You did not know that how many in india loves you, you really did not know that how many new viewers are joined to save you, you did not know that you have a charm that could make even those people to join the show, who never voted for any kind of show. I challenge that could Karunya make anyone, who have not ever voted for any such show, to vote for him?
The target is very near and you have enough to get over all the difficulties.
I am fearing that the next Gala may be a problem for you as you are needed to get your best as you have done confidently in last Gala and also Sonu Nigam wil also not in front of you, but as that Gala song is to be chosen by public and according to the image, you are expected to to get the songs by Udit Narayan again and this will again going to a problem. May god help the best man.
When I joined on the message board then there were few to support Sandeep and many of them even said that the worst ever Final may be that one in which Sandeep Acharya and Anuj Sharma will be in front of each other. I have to say them that their casuality made that fate near. Hoping to see Sandeep and Karunya aganst each in Finals as everyone of us expecting and voting in the same way.
I see Karunya on the leadng edge for tonight (20 March) as he is expected to get the best songs. Hope that Sandeep supporters have gone wisely, now restlessly waiting for the Monday’s night performance. Please God be with us, with Sandeep,we are not expectng to loose him.
I am warning to Sandep’s crazy supporters, that they are becoming a lot of casual after the best of Sandeep Acharya in last Gala, thinking that he got all of the support back to him. I want to remind them that it’s we only we who have made him to come to this point and the competition for him is not became lesser, never tink there is a strom against Anuj Sharma, he is getting much votes and for their suporters it is the last chance and they will do it as they have always did till ths point. So, be carefull. Note that this week may be the next disaster week for Indian Idol, this is the time to vote for the whole day, if not for the whole night, note that seven days for vote does not mean that you have to vote seven times lesser as you usually do. Note that in place of 12 hours now you have 24×7 hours and I am expecting at least more than 14 times of the votes that Sandeep got in the last Gala.
Comeon, you could do it, we could do it and we will make it.
This is really really exclusive that found by searching on Internet,
Check out to see that he was the winner of Semifinals at the link given below:
Could you believe that Amey Date was in SRGMP semifinals 1999 with Shreya Ghosal. It is a kind of shock to me, I did not believe it at first as he was looking just not like today with frenchy, but there are a lot of videos of him and they are to make you sure that it is Amey. I just do not know how to comment on it. I do not know why he didn’t get the sucess while Shreya Ghosal is on the top now. I am really feeling sad that this time, he got much fame, hope that he did not go in darks as he moved into last time from SRGMP.
Although I am still in support with Sandeep Acharya and the above news has nothing to do with my faith in Sandeep Acharya, but I really really praise Sonu Nigam as he was host like Shan in that SRGMP programs where Amey was performing, but he never shows it that he knows Amey from earliar.
Definately, now it is clear Amey was senior of all and he did it as he should. All the best for him.
As I just got the news some minutes ago, so I am not able to place my thought in the manner I usually do, I need some time and I will be back with a new Article or will modify the present one, watch out for that one.
From Nitish Kumar I have found this message on sify’s own message board and in one mroe forum posted by name of Amey Fan!! in Sify’s forum and Sanjay in that I think TV forum.